Do Big Bucks Only Rub Big Trees? Exploring the Myth.



Big bucks do not exclusively rub big trees; they can rub small or moderate trees as well. The size of the tree may depend on the level of rubbing occurring in an area, but bucks may also rub trees for other reasons, such as marking their territory or practicing their movements.

Deer are known for their unique behavior and physical characteristics. As the largest members of the cervidae family, they have a distinctive, muscular body, large antlers, and long legs. Their rubbing behavior is also unique, and it has been a subject of research and fascination for many years.

In this article, we will explore the rub behavior of deer, why they rub trees, and how it affects the environment. We will also discuss why bucks may rub trees during specific seasons and what impact this can have on their health and survival. So, let’s get started!

Do Big Bucks Only Rub Big Trees? Exploring the Myth.


Understanding The Myth

There’s a myth that only big bucks rub big trees during the mating season. However, this is not entirely accurate. The idea originated from the belief that dominant deer can choose the best areas to rub, including large trees. Over time, this idea has spread through hunting culture, even though it’s not entirely true.

Small bucks will also rub trees, and they can do so just as aggressively as their larger counterparts. The truth is that rub patterns can vary depending on the location, health of the population, and the age of the deer.

The perpetuation of this myth only serves to fuel misconceptions about deer behavior and hunting practices, so it’s important to dispel it.

The Science Behind Rubbing

Deer hunters worldwide are well aware that bucks frequently rub trees. But why? Studies have found that the act of rubbing communicates a deer’s status, health and readiness to breed. The smell left by the rub warns off other males and is recognized by nearby females.

The rut, or breeding season, is when bucks will rub the most often and intensely. Hormones drive males to stake their claim on a territory and find a mate. Rubbing will deepen the tone of a buck’s voice, allowing him to sound more impressive.

Additionally, it toughens up his neck, offering a layer of protection during fights for females. Deer hunters must recognize the importance of rubbing during the rut, as it will provide them the best indication of when and where to hunt realistically.

The Role Of Tree Size

Trees play a vital role in a buck’s life. Besides sheltering and providing food, bucks often rub their antlers against trees to remove velvet and mark their territory. But does the size of the tree dictate the size of the buck?

Research has shown that it may not necessarily be the case. Several factors come into play when selecting a tree, including accessibility, texture, and scent. Bucks tend to prefer trees with rough bark, which allows them to effectively remove velvet.

Additionally, trees with stronger scents may attract more bucks. Although there may be some correlation between buck size and preferred tree size, it does not appear to be a definitive factor. Ultimately, the selection of a rubbing tree is unique to each buck and may depend on various factors that are still being researched.

The Influence Of Habitat

The behavior and size of a buck can be impacted by the habitat in which it lives. Food and cover play a significant role in a buck’s rubbing behavior, as trees provide a source of food and cover. Studies have shown that bucks tend to rub trees that are in close proximity to their food and bedding areas.

Additionally, the quality of the habitat also affects a buck’s antler growth and overall size. A buck living in nutrient-rich habitat is likely to have larger antlers and a greater body size than a buck living in a low-quality habitat.

Ultimately, habitat plays a crucial role in the behavior and physical characteristics of bucks, debunking the myth that only big trees rub big bucks.

A Holistic Perspective On Buck Behavior

A holistic perspective on buck behavior reveals its complexity. Genetics, age, time of year, and social dynamics all play a role. The myth that “big bucks only rub big trees” fails to capture the bigger picture. A comprehensive understanding of buck behavior requires a nuanced perspective.

This perspective takes into account factors beyond just the size of the buck. By examining these factors, we can gain insight into the complex and dynamic nature of buck behavior. Understanding this complexity can help us manage deer populations more effectively.

So, let’s look beyond the myth and delve deeper into the dynamic world of buck behavior.

Frequently Asked Questions For Do Big Bucks Only Rub Big Trees?

Do Big Bucks Only Rub Big Trees?

Big bucks don’t necessarily have to rub big trees. They rub trees to remove velvet and mark their territory, and any tree that serves their purpose can be their target. However, mature bucks have a tendency to rub larger trees.

Why Do Bucks Rub Trees?

Bucks rub their antlers against trees to remove the velvet, to mark their territory, and to relieve irritation and itching on their antlers. During the rutting season, bucks also rub trees to attract does and intimidate competitors.

When Do Bucks Start Rubbing Trees?

Bucks start rubbing trees in late summer or early fall when their antlers are fully grown and velvet starts to dry. It marks the beginning of the rutting season, and they continue rubbing trees until the rutting season ends in late november or early december.

How Can I Identify A Buck Rub?

A buck rub is an area on a tree where the bark has been stripped off and shows fresh, smooth wood underneath. The rubs can vary in shape and size depending on the buck’s antlers, and sometimes, they may also have visible hair or marks from the buck’s antlers.

What Kind Of Trees Do Bucks Prefer To Rub?

Bucks may rub any tree that serves their purpose, but they usually prefer trees with softer bark, such as cedar, pine, and sometimes, maple. However, mature bucks have a tendency to rub larger trees, which helps them to leave a more prominent scent mark and show their dominance.

Can A Smaller Tree Handle Buck Rub?

Yes, smaller trees can handle buck rubs, but it may cause some damage that could affect their growth and development. It is always recommended to protect young saplings from buck rubs by wrapping them with wire mesh or applying tree paint or deer repellents.


As we have seen, the myth that big bucks only rub big trees may not be entirely true. While it is true that they use rubbing trees to mark territory and attract mates, research has shown that bucks often use smaller trees and shrubs as well.

Understanding deer behavior and habitat is crucial for any hunter or outdoor enthusiast. It is essential to scout the area before hunting, identify the areas where deer are likely to be spotted, and set up trail cameras to monitor their movement.

The best way to increase your chances of bagging a trophy buck is to know your game, hone your hunting skills, and practice patience. As with any wild animal, there are no guarantees, but maintaining a deep respect for nature and adhering to safety guidelines ensures a safe and rewarding hunting experience.

Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide whether to believe the myth or not, but one thing is for sure: you won’t know until you step into the woods!

About the author